Costs
PetFirst Pet Insurance Reviews: What Happened to the Company and Is
PetFirst is best understood as a predecessor to MetLife Pet rather than a separate insurance product to shop for today.
Key takeaways
PetFirst pet insurance became part of MetLife Pet, so today's coverage, customer service, and policy options should be evaluated through MetLife rather than older PetFirst reviews alone.
- If searching for a PetFirst pet insurance review, the most important thing to understand is that PetFirst Healthcare LLC is the former name of MetLife Pet Insurance Solutions LLC, the company that administers MetLife pet insurance policies.
- MetLife's official disclosures confirm the connection and identify the insurance companies underwriting its current policies.
- That distinction matters because older PetFirst customer reviews describe experiences with a legacy insurance brand, while current MetLife policies have their own coverage terms, exclusions, and claims procedures.
- Anyone considering coverage or trying to resolve an existing claim should establish which policy and insurer apply before making a decision.
Is PetFirst pet insurance still available?
PetFirst is best understood as a predecessor to MetLife Pet rather than a separate insurance product to shop for today.
MetLife's official insurance disclosure confirms that:
• MetLife Pet Insurance Solutions LLC is the policy administrator.
• The administrator was previously known as PetFirst Healthcare LLC.
• The company is authorized to administer policies underwritten by Independence American Insurance Company and Metropolitan General Insurance Company.
• In some states, the administrator continues to operate under the PetFirst Healthcare name while awaiting approval of a name change.
This explains why PetFirst and MetLife names can both appear in insurance documents.
What this means for shoppers: Compare current MetLife Pet coverage and pricing rather than relying on an old PetFirst advertisement, quotation, or comparison chart.
What this means for existing customers: An older PetFirst policy should not automatically be treated as identical to a newly issued MetLife policy. The original policy documents determine the applicable coverage.
What do PetFirst pet insurance reviews actually say?
Historical customer feedback is mixed, with particularly important concerns about claims administration and communication.
The PetFirst profile on Trustpilot displays 223 reviews and indicates that no reviews were submitted during the preceding 12 months. Its visible reviews include experiences from both the PetFirst and MetLife periods.
Several recurring themes appear in negative customer accounts.
1. Claim delays and documentation requests
Some customers describe having to submit veterinary records and invoices repeatedly, difficulty uploading documents, and claims remaining unresolved while additional information was requested.
This makes documentation an important consideration when evaluating the claims experience.
2. Disagreements about claim denials
Some reviewers describe disputes involving pre-existing conditions, preventive-care exclusions, and whether particular treatments qualified for reimbursement.
These complaints highlight an important distinction: a veterinary expense does not automatically qualify for reimbursement simply because a veterinarian recommended the treatment.
3. Premium increases
Some customers report increases in their monthly premiums and dissatisfaction with changes to their policy costs.
A review of the initial premium alone does not establish whether insurance will remain affordable at renewal.
4. Positive experiences with reimbursement
Not every customer account is negative. Some reviewers describe successful reimbursement for substantial veterinary expenses, including treatment for bladder stones.
How much weight should these reviews carry?
Trustpilot reviews can identify potential customer-service problems, but they cannot establish the probability that a particular claim will be approved.
There are also limitations to the available feedback:
• The reviews span different years and potentially different policy arrangements.
• Some reviews concern MetLife-branded coverage rather than the original PetFirst experience.
• The profile has no reviews in its most recent 12-month reporting period.
• Trustpilot itself cautions that the available reviews may not be representative.
The practical conclusion is to treat historical reviews as warning signs worth investigating, not as a definitive prediction of current MetLife claims performance.
What did PetFirst pet insurance cover?
A published PetFirst-branded accident and illness policy provides a useful example of the coverage previously offered.
The sample policy was issued by Independence American Insurance Company and identified PetFirst Pet Insurance as the administrator. Its covered veterinary services included eligible expenses for:
• Accidental injuries
• Illnesses and diseases
• Certain hereditary and genetic conditions
• Chronic conditions
• Veterinary examinations associated with covered treatment
• Surgery
• X-rays, ultrasounds, and other diagnostic testing
• Laboratory work
• Hospitalization
• Prescribed medications
• Certain alternative and complementary therapies
Coverage depended on the applicable policy provisions, waiting periods, exclusions, and benefit limits.
Accident and illness coverage
Accident and illness insurance is designed to help reimburse eligible expenses when a pet develops a covered medical problem after enrollment and applicable waiting periods.
For example, the published PetFirst policy included eligible treatment for injuries such as fractures and animal bites, as well as illnesses such as cancer and other chronic conditions.
However, a condition's inclusion in a coverage description does not guarantee reimbursement. Its timing, medical history, and applicable exclusions still matter.
Optional wellness coverage
Routine veterinary care was not automatically included in the standard accident and illness coverage.
The PetFirst sample policy offered optional wellness benefits with separate reimbursement schedules for expenses such as:
• Wellness examinations
• Vaccinations
• Certain parasite-prevention expenses
• Preventive testing
• Spaying and neutering
• Dental cleaning
Each benefit was subject to its own maximum reimbursement amount.
This distinction matters when comparing insurance premiums. A policy with an optional wellness benefit is not necessarily paying the full cost of routine veterinary care.
PetFirst coverage exclusions and waiting periods
The most important coverage details are often found in the exclusions and definitions rather than the advertised benefits.
Pre-existing conditions
The PetFirst sample policy defined pre-existing conditions to include illnesses or injuries that first occurred or showed clinical signs before the original policy start date or the end of the applicable waiting period.
Undiagnosed conditions displaying the same clinical signs could also qualify as pre-existing.
This can affect claims even when a condition had not received a formal diagnosis before enrollment.
For example, if a dog had documented symptoms of an orthopedic problem before coverage began, subsequent treatment might be excluded under the applicable policy wording.
MetLife's current policy information similarly identifies pre-existing conditions as generally excluded, although certain curable conditions may become eligible when a later occurrence is unrelated to the earlier condition.
Waiting periods
The published PetFirst policy issued by Independence American Insurance Company specified:
• Coverage — Waiting period
• Accidental injuries — 1 day
• Illnesses — 14 days
• Orthopedic conditions in dogs — 6 months
These are the terms in that particular sample policy, not universal waiting periods for every PetFirst customer.
Current MetLife Pet policies have different published waiting-period information, including no waiting period for accidents and a 14-day illness waiting period.
Always check the actual policy rather than assuming that current MetLife terms apply retroactively to an older PetFirst contract.
Annual benefit limits
The PetFirst sample policy capped reimbursement at the annual maximum benefit shown in the policy schedule.
The amount available therefore depended on the specific policy purchased.
Current MetLife Pet coverage offers customizable annual limits starting at $500, with an unlimited option available for eligible policies.
Other exclusions
The PetFirst sample policy also excluded certain expenses, including:
• Preventive care unless optional wellness coverage applied.
• Certain treatments involving persistent neglect.
• Certain boarding and transportation expenses.
• Treatment for deliberately caused injuries or illnesses.
• Certain experimental treatments.
The complete exclusion list and any applicable endorsements should be reviewed before assuming a treatment is covered.
PetFirst claims, reimbursement, and customer service
Pet insurance generally operates through reimbursement rather than automatic payment of veterinary bills.
Under the published PetFirst policy, customers were responsible for paying their veterinary providers and submitting the required claim documentation. The policy required itemized invoices and veterinary records.
MetLife's current claims process similarly requires customers to pay the veterinary bill and request reimbursement for eligible expenses.
What documents are needed?
MetLife currently identifies the following as important claim documents:
• An itemized veterinary invoice.
• Veterinary medical records, also called SOAP notes.
• The preceding 12 months of veterinary records, or adoption paperwork when applicable, for the first claim.
Keeping copies of all invoices, examination records, diagnostic reports, and claim correspondence can help resolve documentation disputes.
How long do claims take?
MetLife states that most claims are processed within five to ten days when all necessary documentation is provided upfront. Additional information requests can extend the processing time.
This is a current MetLife processing estimate, not a guarantee of the time required for an older PetFirst policy or a disputed claim.
What if a claim is denied?
A denial should be reviewed against the actual policy language.
The published PetFirst sample policy provides an appeal procedure that includes:
1. Requesting a formal appeal within the applicable 90-day period.
2. Requesting an external review if dissatisfied with the first appeal decision.
3. Filing a complaint with the relevant state Department of Insurance if the dispute remains unresolved.
For current MetLife policies, follow the appeal instructions and deadlines in the applicable policy and explanation of benefits.
A useful appeal should identify the specific denied expense, explain why the policy appears to cover it, and include supporting veterinary records and relevant policy language.
Should you choose MetLife Pet instead of PetFirst?
For someone shopping for a new policy, MetLife Pet is the relevant current offering to investigate.
Its published coverage options include:
• Feature — Current MetLife Pet offering
• Reimbursement — Up to 90%
• Annual deductible — $0 to $2,500
• Annual benefit limit — $500 to unlimited
• Accident coverage — Available
• Illness coverage — Available
• Hereditary conditions — Eligible conditions may be covered
• Chronic conditions — Eligible conditions may be covered
• Preventive care — Optional coverage
• Multiple pets — Family plans available
Availability and restrictions vary by policy and state.
Potential advantages
MetLife Pet offers several features worth considering:
• Customizable deductibles and reimbursement percentages.
• An option for unlimited annual benefits.
• Coverage for eligible chronic and hereditary conditions.
• Optional preventive-care benefits.
• Family plans that can include multiple pets.
• Freedom to visit licensed veterinarians, emergency clinics, and specialists in the United States.
Potential disadvantages
There are also important limitations:
• Pre-existing conditions are generally excluded.
• Routine care usually requires optional preventive coverage.
• Customers must pay veterinary bills before receiving reimbursement.
• Annual limits and deductibles can substantially affect out-of-pocket costs.
• Claims may take longer when additional documentation is needed.
What should be compared before purchasing?
Rather than choosing based on brand recognition or historical reviews, compare the following:
• Comparison point — What to check
• Monthly premium — Total cost over a year
• Deductible — Amount paid before reimbursement
• Reimbursement — Percentage of eligible expenses returned
• Annual limit — Maximum yearly reimbursement
• Pre-existing conditions — Definition and exceptions
• Waiting periods — Accident, illness, and orthopedic coverage
• Dental coverage — Illness, injury, and routine cleaning
• Prescription coverage — Eligible medications
• Wellness coverage — Preventive-care reimbursement limits
• Renewal terms — Premium changes and coverage conditions
A lower monthly premium can result in higher expenses when a major veterinary claim occurs. The deductible, reimbursement rate, and annual maximum should be evaluated together.
What existing PetFirst policyholders should do
If an existing policy still carries the PetFirst name, the priority is to establish the current policy status and avoid accidentally losing valuable coverage.
Follow these steps:
1. Find the original policy documents. Locate the declarations page, policy number, insurer, benefit schedule, and policy form.
1. Confirm who administers the policy. Contact MetLife Pet and ask whether the policy is currently administered through its MyPets system.
1. Verify the coverage that remains active. Check the deductible, reimbursement percentage, annual limit, waiting periods, and exclusions.
1. Review the pet's medical history. Make sure previously covered conditions and ongoing treatments are clearly documented.
1. Keep claim records. Save itemized invoices, SOAP notes, claim confirmations, explanations of benefits, and written correspondence.
1. Check claim and appeal deadlines. Do not assume that an older policy has the same procedures as a newly issued MetLife policy.
1. Get written confirmation before switching. If considering another insurer, establish how existing conditions and continuous coverage will be treated before canceling the current policy.
This last step is especially important when a pet has an ongoing medical condition. A replacement policy may treat previously documented problems as pre-existing conditions.
Frequently asked questions
Is PetFirst pet insurance still in business?
PetFirst Healthcare LLC is the former name of MetLife Pet Insurance Solutions LLC, which currently administers MetLife pet insurance policies. PetFirst may still appear in certain state-specific corporate or policy documents.
Is PetFirst pet insurance the same as MetLife?
They are closely connected. MetLife's official disclosure identifies MetLife Pet Insurance Solutions LLC as the successor to the PetFirst Healthcare LLC name. Current policies are administered under MetLife Pet, although the specific insurer and contract terms depend on the policy.
Is PetFirst pet insurance good?
Historical customer reviews are mixed. Some customers describe successful reimbursements, while others report claim delays, documentation problems, denials, and premium increases. The available Trustpilot reviews are not recent enough to establish the quality of current MetLife service.
Did PetFirst cover pre-existing conditions?
Generally, no. The published PetFirst policy excluded pre-existing conditions, including certain illnesses and injuries that showed clinical signs before the policy start date or during waiting periods.
Did PetFirst pet insurance cover routine veterinary care?
Routine care was not automatically included in standard accident and illness coverage. The published sample policy offered optional wellness benefits with separate reimbursement limits.
How long did PetFirst take to reimburse claims?
The published PetFirst policy required payment within 30 days after receiving all necessary documentation. Current MetLife information indicates that most complete claims are processed within five to ten days, although additional documentation can cause delays. These are different policy and administrative arrangements.
Can an existing PetFirst policy be transferred to another insurance company?
A new policy should not be assumed to preserve the original policy's coverage history. Before switching, obtain written confirmation of how existing conditions, waiting periods, and continuous coverage will be handled.
What should someone do about an unresolved PetFirst claim?
Identify the insurer and administrator on the policy, collect the itemized invoice and veterinary records, and request a written explanation of the claim decision. Follow the appeal procedure in the applicable policy. The published PetFirst sample policy also identifies the right to contact the state Department of Insurance if a dispute remains unresolved.
Editorial standards
Who wrote this guide
Written by VetWayfinder Editorial Team.
Every factual statement is tied to a cited source listed below. Report an error through the corrections page.
Sources
Each source supports at least one factual statement in this guide.
