Costs

Can You Change Pet Insurance Mid Policy? What to Know

Yes, you can change pet insurance mid-policy, but the options depend on whether you adjust your current plan or switch insurance companies.

Key takeaways

Yes, you can change pet insurance mid-policy, but the options depend on whether you adjust your current plan or switch insurance companies.

  • Changing pet insurance does not always require waiting until your policy renews.
  • Some providers let you change your deductible, reimbursement percentage, annual coverage limit, or optional benefits during the policy year.
  • Others restrict certain changes until renewal.
  • Switching to another insurance company is also possible, but it can affect waiting periods, pre-existing condition exclusions, and the cost of coverage.
  • Before making a change, compare the new premium with the coverage you already have.
  • A lower monthly payment may come with higher out-of-pocket expenses or less protection for conditions your pet has already experienced.

Typical Costs When Changing Pet Insurance

Changing pet insurance does not have one standard price.

The cost depends on the adjustments you make, your current insurer's billing rules, and whether you purchase a completely new policy.

For a general cost benchmark, the North American Pet Health Insurance Association's 2026 industry report provides average U.S. premiums based on 2025 data.

• Type of coverage — Dogs, annual average — Cats, annual average

• Accident-only — $190 — $112

• Accident and illness — $836 — $435

• Insurance with embedded wellness — $1,414 — $859

These figures represent approximately $16 to $118 per month for dogs and $9 to $72 per month for cats, depending on the coverage category. They are industry averages, not guaranteed prices or fees for changing an existing policy.

When changing an existing policy, the insurer may recalculate your premium based on the new coverage selections.

For example:

• Increasing your annual deductible can lower your monthly premium.

• Lowering your reimbursement percentage can reduce the amount you pay for coverage.

• Increasing your annual coverage limit can raise your premium.

• Adding wellness or preventive care benefits can increase the total cost.

• Switching companies can result in a completely different premium based on the new provider's pricing.

Some insurers also calculate a prorated charge or credit when coverage changes take effect before the next renewal date. The amount depends on the policy and the effective date of the adjustment.

Treat national averages as budgeting estimates rather than quotes for an individual pet.

What Changes the Cost of Your Policy?

Several factors influence the price of pet insurance when you change coverage or move to another provider.

Your pet's age and breed

Age and breed can affect the cost of a new policy. Older pets may have higher premiums because they are more likely to need veterinary treatment.

Some insurers also have age restrictions for new enrollments. Switching companies when your pet is older could limit the available options, even if your current insurer continues covering the pet.

Breed can also influence pricing because certain breeds have higher risks of hereditary or breed-related health conditions.

Your location

Pet insurance premiums can change when you move to another city or state.

Veterinary treatment costs vary by location, and insurers consider regional expenses when calculating premiums. A policy that costs less in one area may have a higher price in another.

Your deductible and reimbursement percentage

Your deductible is the amount you pay toward eligible veterinary expenses before insurance reimbursement begins.

Your reimbursement percentage determines how much of an eligible expense the insurer pays after applying the deductible.

A higher deductible generally reduces the premium, while a lower deductible usually increases it. Choosing a lower reimbursement percentage can also reduce the monthly payment.

Your annual coverage limit

An annual coverage limit determines the maximum amount an insurer will reimburse during a policy year.

A plan with a lower annual limit generally costs less than one with a higher limit. However, a lower limit also means you could pay more yourself if your pet needs expensive treatment.

Veterinary costs and policy adjustments

Premiums can increase at renewal because veterinary treatment, medications, and other healthcare expenses become more expensive.

Some insurers also adjust premiums when a pet gets older or the policyholder changes location. These adjustments can happen even when the owner has not filed a claim.

The National Association of Insurance Commissioners identifies species, breed, gender, age, location, coverage, and deductible as factors affecting pet insurance prices.

A lower premium should not come at the expense of coverage your pet may need.

Fees and Costs People Often Miss

The advertised monthly premium is not necessarily the only expense involved in changing pet insurance.

Several additional costs can affect the final amount.

Payment processing fees

Some insurers charge processing fees depending on the payment schedule.

For example, Pets Best lists a $2 processing fee for monthly, quarterly, and semiannual premium payments in its November 2026 FAQ. The fee does not apply to annual payments or customers living in Alaska, Maryland, or New Hampshire.

Pets Best also allows customers to contact its customer service team to change their payment frequency after enrollment.

This is an insurer-specific example, not a standard fee across the pet insurance industry.

New waiting periods

Switching insurance companies can mean starting new waiting periods.

A waiting period is the time between the beginning of a policy and the date certain coverage becomes available.

For example, a new insurer may require a waiting period before covering illnesses or certain orthopedic conditions. Your previous insurer's waiting periods generally do not transfer automatically to a different company.

Embrace also explains that increasing coverage on an existing policy can trigger re-underwriting and reset waiting periods.

Pre-existing condition exclusions

This is one of the most important costs to consider before switching.

A new insurer may classify an illness or injury as pre-existing if your pet showed symptoms, received treatment, or had a diagnosis before the new policy began or during its waiting period.

For example, a pet with a history of allergies, arthritis, digestive problems, or an orthopedic injury may not receive coverage for related treatment under a new policy.

Your existing insurer may already cover some of these conditions under your current contract. Changing companies could mean losing that protection.

Cancellation fees and refunds

Cancellation rules differ between insurance providers and states.

For example, Embrace offers a full refund when a policyholder cancels within the first 30 days of the initial policy start date without submitting claims. After the free-look period, a prorated refund may be available under its cancellation rules.

The insurer calculates eligible prorated refunds based on the remaining billing period, and state-specific cancellation provisions may apply.

Additional wellness charges

Optional wellness benefits can have separate payment rules.

Embrace's Wellness Rewards program is a non-insurance benefit. Adding or increasing it during an existing policy year requires a one-time back-payment for the months dating back to the beginning of the current policy period.

The program is also not prorated, so adding it mid-policy can create an unexpected expense.

Never assume that cancellation, refunds, or coverage changes are free simply because the insurer allows mid-policy adjustments.

Ways to Pay or Finance a Policy Change

Changing pet insurance can affect both your monthly budget and the amount you need to pay immediately.

Understanding the available payment arrangements can help prevent an unexpected financial gap.

Monthly premium payments

Monthly payments spread the insurance cost throughout the year.

This arrangement can make coverage easier to budget for, particularly when changing to a more expensive plan.

Some insurers automatically charge a credit card, debit card, or bank account each month. Others allow customers to update payment information through an online account.

Quarterly, semiannual, or annual payments

Some providers offer payment schedules beyond monthly installments.

Pets Best offers monthly, quarterly, semiannual, and annual payment arrangements. Its processing fee structure also makes payment frequency worth comparing before choosing a new schedule.

Lemonade offers monthly and annual payment options, with an annual payment discount of up to 5% for eligible policies.

Annual payments can reduce certain transaction costs, but they require more money upfront.

Employer-sponsored payment arrangements

Some employers offer pet insurance as a voluntary workplace benefit.

Depending on the arrangement, premiums may be collected through payroll deductions. Employees should contact their human resources department or benefits administrator to understand payment schedules and whether existing coverage can be changed.

Financing veterinary expenses

Pet insurance and veterinary financing serve different purposes.

Most pet insurance policies operate on a reimbursement basis. This means the owner pays the veterinary bill first, submits a claim, and receives reimbursement for eligible expenses after the insurer reviews the claim.

If switching insurers creates a temporary period without coverage, the owner may need to pay veterinary expenses without reimbursement.

For larger veterinary bills, ask the clinic whether it offers payment arrangements or accepts third-party veterinary financing. These options help pay for veterinary treatment rather than the insurance premium itself.

Avoid missing a premium payment while arranging a new payment schedule, because unpaid premiums can put coverage at risk.

How to Lower the Cost of Pet Insurance

If the main reason for changing pet insurance is affordability, adjusting the existing policy may be less disruptive than switching companies.

Several changes can reduce the monthly premium.

Increase your annual deductible

A higher deductible generally lowers the premium.

However, you must pay more toward eligible veterinary expenses before the insurer starts reimbursing claims.

Choose an amount that you could realistically afford if your pet needs unexpected treatment.

Reduce your reimbursement percentage

Lowering the reimbursement percentage can reduce the monthly cost.

For example, moving from a higher reimbursement level to a lower one means the insurer pays a smaller share of eligible expenses.

The remaining amount becomes your responsibility.

Choose a lower annual coverage limit

A lower annual limit can make insurance more affordable.

However, a pet requiring surgery, cancer treatment, or ongoing care could reach the limit more quickly.

Compare the savings against the potential cost of expensive veterinary treatment.

Remove optional benefits

Wellness packages and additional coverage options can increase the total premium.

If you already pay separately for routine veterinary expenses, removing an optional wellness package may reduce your insurance costs.

Check whether removing the benefit affects any existing claims or membership obligations.

Compare multi-pet discounts

Some providers offer discounts when multiple pets are insured under eligible plans.

For example, Pets Best lists a 5% multi-pet discount for qualifying policies, while Lemonade advertises multi-pet discounts of up to 10%.

Discount availability and eligibility depend on the insurer and policy.

Compare equivalent policies

When considering a new insurer, compare plans with similar deductibles, reimbursement percentages, annual limits, and exclusions.

A cheaper policy may offer substantially less coverage than your current one.

Also compare how each company handles pre-existing conditions, waiting periods, prescription medications, specialist care, and chronic illnesses.

If your pet already has a medical history, keeping the existing policy and reducing optional coverage may be more practical than starting over with another insurer.

Only reduce coverage after considering the additional veterinary expenses you may have to pay yourself.

Questions to Ask Before Paying for a Change

Before changing your pet insurance, contact your current provider and any prospective insurer to confirm the financial and coverage details.

The following questions can help prevent unexpected expenses.

1. Can I change my coverage before renewal? Ask which adjustments are available immediately and which require waiting until the next policy year.

1. Will the change require new underwriting? Find out whether the insurer will review your pet's medical history again and whether approval is required.

1. Will my waiting periods restart? Confirm whether increasing coverage or purchasing a new policy creates new waiting periods for illnesses, injuries, or orthopedic conditions.

1. What happens to my pet's existing conditions? Ask whether previously covered illnesses, injuries, symptoms, and ongoing treatments will remain eligible for reimbursement.

1. What will my new premium be? Request the exact monthly and annual amounts, including processing fees, optional benefits, and any additional charges.

1. Will I receive a refund from my current policy? Ask how the insurer calculates refunds, whether cancellation fees apply, and when the cancellation becomes effective.

1. When does the new coverage begin? Request the exact effective date and confirmation that the new policy has been approved.

1. What happens to pending claims? Ask which policy will handle claims for veterinary treatment received before the change takes effect.

1. Can I reverse the change later? Some insurers restrict future upgrades after coverage has been reduced, so confirm whether the original benefits can be restored.

Before switching companies, request your pet's complete medical records and ask your veterinarian to clarify any documented symptoms, diagnoses, and ongoing treatments. This information can help you understand what a new insurer may classify as pre-existing.

Request the revised policy documents and premium breakdown in writing before authorizing payment or cancelling your current coverage.

Keep your existing policy active until the replacement policy has been approved and its coverage is effective.

Frequently asked questions

Can you switch pet insurance companies before your policy expires?

Yes. You can apply for a new policy without waiting for your existing policy to reach its renewal date. However, the new insurer will apply its own eligibility requirements, exclusions, and waiting periods. Arrange the new coverage before cancelling the existing policy to avoid a gap.

Will filing a pet insurance claim automatically increase your premium?

Not necessarily. Premium pricing depends on the insurer and its rating rules. For example, ASPCA Pet Health Insurance states that filing claims will never result in a rate change for its program. Other premium adjustments may still occur because of factors such as age, location, and veterinary treatment costs.

Can you transfer pet insurance to another owner?

It depends on the insurance company. Some policies may be transferred with the insurer's written approval, while others do not allow ownership transfers. Lemonade, for example, does not allow its pet insurance policies to be transferred to another owner. Contact the insurer before changing ownership so the pet's coverage arrangements can be reviewed.

Can you change from accident-only to accident-and-illness coverage?

Not every insurer allows this change under an existing policy. Some require a new enrollment rather than a simple coverage adjustment. A new enrollment can involve a new premium, underwriting review, waiting periods, and pre-existing condition exclusions. Confirm the requirements before giving up your current plan.

Editorial standards

Who wrote this guide

Written by VetWayfinder Editorial Team.

Every factual statement is tied to a cited source listed below. Report an error through the corrections page.